Of all the failures exposed on October 7, 2023, the most catastrophic may have been one of strategy, not just security. In a revealing interview, Yehuda Shaul, co-founder of the Israeli veterans' organization Breaking the Silence, presents a damning indictment of the Israeli government’s pre-war political calculus. He argues that the devastating Hamas attack was not a simple intelligence or tactical blunder, but the direct result of a long-standing policy: deliberately weakening the Palestinian Authority while bolstering Hamas in Gaza, under the illusion that the conflict could be indefinitely "managed" by military might. This prioritization, Shaul explains, was starkly visible in the disproportionate deployment of troops, with more soldiers protecting a few hundred settlers in Hebron than were stationed on the entire Gaza border that morning. October 7th, therefore, was not an isolated security breach but the inevitable explosion of a failed paradigm, proving that a strategy of perpetual control over millions of Palestinians ultimately undermines Israel's own security.
Playback speed
×
Share post
Share post at current time
Share from 0:00
0:00
/
0:00
Transcript
On October 7th, Israel abandoned the south
In conversation with Yehuda Shaul, founder of Breaking the Silence
Sep 23, 2025
Inconclusive Thoughts
Welcome to Inconclusive Thoughts, the podcast where we slow down to thoughtfully analyze and discuss the stories shaping our world. In each episode, we provide in-depth commentary on politics and culture, carefully unpacking the implications of current events.
Join us for deliberate discussions that emphasize understanding over quick opinions. We feature insightful analysis, thought-provoking commentary, and interviews with remarkable guests who offer unique perspectives.
Inconclusive Thoughts is your refuge for reflective discourse in an often overwhelming media landscape. Tune in and explore the complexities of today's most pressing issues with us, one conversation at a time.
Welcome to Inconclusive Thoughts, the podcast where we slow down to thoughtfully analyze and discuss the stories shaping our world. In each episode, we provide in-depth commentary on politics and culture, carefully unpacking the implications of current events.
Join us for deliberate discussions that emphasize understanding over quick opinions. We feature insightful analysis, thought-provoking commentary, and interviews with remarkable guests who offer unique perspectives.
Inconclusive Thoughts is your refuge for reflective discourse in an often overwhelming media landscape. Tune in and explore the complexities of today's most pressing issues with us, one conversation at a time.Listen on
Substack App
Spotify
RSS Feed
Appears in episode
Recent Episodes











